Friday, May 22, 2009

Bava Metzia 27 - Are Identifying Marks Torah Law? (Finds)

The commandment to return lost objects states, "...and so shall you do with his garment...and with any lost article..."

The garment is already included in "any lost article," so what does it teach? - Just as a garment is unique in that it has identifying marks and claimants (owners), so too, anything that has identifying marks must be announced. However, one is not obligated to return a lost object that the owner has despaired of recovering. 

Do we see from this ruling that identifying marks are from the Torah? No. The ruling might be primarily interested in the second part, the owner's despair, and mention the marks only incidentally.

Art: The Poet's Garden by Vincent Van Gogh


No comments: